Leaders.com
  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Wealth
  • Master Classes
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurs
    • Executives
    • Marketing and Sales
    • Social Media
    • Innovation
    • Women in Business
  • Leadership
    • Personal Growth
    • Company Culture
    • Public Speaking
    • Productivity
    • Hiring
    • Social Issues
    • Leaders
  • Wealth
    • Investing
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Retirement
    • Venture Capital
    • Loans and Borrowing
    • Taxes
    • Markets
    • Real Estate
  • Master Classes
Hiring Handshake

Is DEI harming hiring processes? (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)

By Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff

Tyler Hummel

Tyler Hummel

Tyler Hummel is a news writer for Leaders Media. He was the Fall 2021 College Fix Fellow and Health Care...

Full bio


Learn about our editorial policy

Nov 4, 2022

A Hiring Method That Isn’t Working 

Prioritizing diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) in hiring seems to make it harder to find candidates.

Key Details

  • A former manager at Microsoft—writing under the pseudonym Jason Mansfield—spoke with the non-profit Center for the Study of Partisanship and Ideology about the company’s internal DEI practices. 
  • He is speaking out because he feels that current hiring practices are making it harder to hire qualified candidates. 
  • “I became concerned about diversity and inclusion policies that required me to sacrifice what I viewed as the best way to serve the company’s mission, particularly as it affected work prioritization, hiring, and promotions,” says Mansfield. 
  • “I’m publishing this article pseudonymously because I fear I would be fired or many companies would in the future refuse to hire me for writing it,” he says. 
  • Black Americans represent 13.6% of the U.S. population but only represented 3.7% of Microsoft executives in 2020. That increased to 5.6% in 2021.

Why it’s important

Over the past several years, DEI practices have become a major factor in hiring practices and promotion for major corporations. 

Mansfield claims that Microsoft’s publicly stated aims to address racial equity are affecting hiring and human resources at all levels and making business harder. He also claims that employees will only be considered for promotion if they write publicly available statements showing their dedication to DEI. 

The problem

Mansfield spent months searching through external candidates on LinkedIn and the hiring process bottlenecked as qualified diverse candidates slowly trickled in. HR’s desire to improve diversity and inclusion slowed down several projects his team was working on as roles went unfilled. 

“As a hiring manager, I was told that for any position to be filled in the United States I had to interview: At least one African-American, black, Hispanic, or Latin candidate, and at least one female candidate,” he says. 

Notable quote

“When I began my career, I believed that the systems for determining who got a job or a promotion at a company like Microsoft at least aimed at an ideal of meritocracy. Now I believe Microsoft hires and promotes people partly based on their group identities,” says Mansfield. 

“I fear that when large companies hire and promote people based on group identities, it discourages individuals from cultivating their abilities and ultimately hurts the corporate mission.” 

Home / News / A Hiring Method That Isn’t Working 
Share
FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Related Stories

61% Of Americans Are Living Paycheck-To-Paycheck 

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff
Markets

Sep 8, 2023

Nearly two-thirds of Americans are feeling pinched by inflation. 

Key Details

  • LendingClub’s newest research shows that 61% of adults lived paycheck-to-paycheck in July 2023, increasing from 59% in July 2022. 
  • Even with inflation decreasing from 8.5% to 3.2% in 12 months, consumers still struggle to get by.  
  • A portion of this is attributed to irresponsible spending, with 21% of survey respondents saying nonessential spending is responsible for their financial issues. 
  • Low-income consumers—making less than $50,000 per year—were among the hardest hit by tightening wallets, Fortune reports. 
  • Bankrate’s Annual Emergency Fund Report earlier this year found that 57% of Americans cannot afford a $1,000 emergency. 

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Google Cracks Down On A.I. Election Ads

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff
Tech

Sep 7, 2023

Political campaigns using artificial intelligence (AI) generated content must disclose this information in Google and YouTube content. 

Key Details

  • Google has revealed a new disclosure policy that will force election advertisers to label AI content distinctly from real content. 
  • As of mid-November, generative AI content must receive a label to make it clearly identifiable to avoid spreading election misinformation. 
  • Google’s digital ad business joins companies like Meta Platform’s Facebook and Instagram in cracking down on deep fakes and spreading misinformation. 

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Vivek Ramaswamy’s Anti-ESG Firm Is Worth $1 Billion 

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff
Environment

Sep 7, 2023

The third most popular GOP presidential candidate has built his name fighting “wokeness”—and that reputation is paying off for his asset management company. 

Key Details

  • Ohio-based Strive Asset Management is an anti-activism fund company that promises investors higher-quality returns and investments.  
  • It was partly founded by Peter Thiel and Bill Ackman to rival investors at environmental, social, and governance (ESG)-friendly firms. 
  • On Tuesday, the firm announced that its accumulated assets now exceed $1 billion, slightly more than a year after it launched in 2022. 
  • The company is also currently facing lawsuits from two former employees arguing that it mistreats staff and engages in securities violations.

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Investing

Sep 7, 2023

Bill Gates Makes a $96.6 Million Bud Light Bet

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff
Cryptocurrency

Sep 6, 2023

Cathie Wood Bets Bullish On Big Tech 

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff
Some U.S. companies are finding it easier to hire help, after a rough few years
Hiring

Sep 6, 2023

Promotions Can Increase the Number Of Employees Quitting 

by Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff

Recent Articles

Business

Sep 18, 2023

25 Recession-Proof Jobs That Keep People From Getting Laid Off at Work

Learn what the safest jobs are during an economic downturn

Leadership

Sep 14, 2023

Maladaptive Daydreaming Signs + 4 Ways to Manage Them

Maladaptive daydreaming involves daydreams that interfere with daily functioning

Hiring

Sep 13, 2023

40 Smart Questions to Ask at the End of an Interview to Get Hired

Impress hiring managers with these thoughtful questions

  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Wealth
Join the Leaders Community

Get exclusive tools and resources you need to grow as a leader and scale a purpose-driven business.

Subscribing indicates your consent to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Leaders.com
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Careers
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms
  • Disclosures
  • Editorial Policy
  • Member Login

© 2023 Leaders.com - All rights reserved.

Search Leaders.com