Leaders.com
  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Wealth
  • Master Classes
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurs
    • Executives
    • Marketing and Sales
    • Social Media
    • Innovation
    • Women in Business
  • Leadership
    • Personal Growth
    • Company Culture
    • Public Speaking
    • Productivity
    • Hiring
    • Social Issues
    • Leaders
  • Wealth
    • Investing
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Retirement
    • Venture Capital
    • Loans and Borrowing
    • Taxes
    • Markets
    • Real Estate
  • Master Classes
Cryptocurrency Bitcoin

The Bitcoin Policy Institute encourages responsible regulation (Jonathan Raa/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

By Tyler Hummel Leaders Staff

Tyler Hummel

Tyler Hummel

Tyler Hummel is a news writer for Leaders Media. He was the Fall 2021 College Fix Fellow and Health Care...

Full bio


Learn about our editorial policy

Mar 8, 2023

The Future Of Bitcoin Regulation 

Most agree that cryptocurrencies need a new regulatory structure, but advocates stand against the tide of government critics—saying the structure has the potential to be useful if it is regulated responsibly. 

Key Details

  • David Zell is the co-executive director of the Bitcoin Policy Institute and co-authored a June 2022 congressional letter encouraging responsible Bitcoin policy. 
  • Speaking with Leaders Media, he says Bitcoin has more benefits than risks and that the SEC needs to provide a more transparent regulatory framework. 
  • Bitcoin has become a more popular investment tool in the U.S. However, its future as an investment is clouded by regulatory uncertainty, given that the SEC may change its policy.
  • This uncertainty has pushed many crypto exchanges to set up outside the U.S. in countries like The Bahamas, an essential signal to policymakers that the industry can’t operate within the current regulatory framework. 
  • Zell recommends that individual currencies be regulated on a case-by-case basis, but a clear structure from the SEC is necessary.

Why It’s Important 

The federal government’s crypto crackdown has been coming for a long time following the precipitous collapses of Terraform Labs, Celsius, Voyager, Three Arrows Capital, and FTX added urgency to the reaction. However, the critique of crypto goes back further than FTX’s cataclysmic collapse. 

In the past few months, the White House, the Department of Justice, the SEC, the Federal Reserve, and Congress have all advocated cracking down on crypto. Most recently, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) began filing lawsuits on the ground that crypto counted as a security, when its stance on whether individual currencies qualify as commodities or securities has been vague. 

Bitcoin was launched in 2009 and started to popularize after 2012. Its critics have laid numerous criticisms against the currency in the decade since—namely, it is highly damaging to the environment due to the amount of energy Bitcoin mining draws and is tied very closely to money laundering and crime. 

The World Economic Forum (WEF) reports that the global energy usage of crypto miners was more significant than the individual power consumption of 159 nations and offsets clean energy gains. Forbes claims that “more than half of all reported [crypto] trading volume is likely to be fake” or otherwise illegal or fraudulent. Bitcoin first came to notoriety due to the rise of Silk Road, a dark-web drug-trafficking website taken down in 2013 that only accepted payments in crypto. 

In Defense of Bitcoin 

Zell notes that critiques of Bitcoin are generally accurate but overstated and that many of the more catastrophizing arguments from the WEF against crypto have circled through Washington, D.C., without much scrutiny or consideration. These critiques overlook the stated benefits of Bitcoin and exaggerate the environmental impact of Bitcoin mining, according to advocates. He expects “ESG-style” attacks on Bitcoin will continue to mount over the coming months as the federal government lays out its critique.  

“The term ‘digital asset’ is so broad. Since Bitcoin was invented, 13,000 to 16,000 cryptocurrencies have been created, and the majority have lost most of their value. The overwhelming majority have been blatant Ponzi schemes. When we talk about policy, it’s hard to talk about Bitcoin and Dogecoin similarly. They’re so different. The message we at the Bitcoin Policy Institute prioritize is reinforcing the notion that Bitcoin is different than most cryptocurrencies. Its benefits outweigh its risks, more so than most of crypto,” says Zell.  

Zell notes that a growing bipartisan consensus in favor of Bitcoin and crypto has increased in the nation’s capital. Center-right organizations in D.C., like the Club for Growth, the Cato Institute, and the Heritage Foundation, are opposing anti-crypto policies and seeing some support from left-of-center groups worried about privacy and freedom.

He says there are many uses for Bitcoin that have ethical and even humanitarian uses. As he notes in his congressional letter, it is used worldwide in countries with unstable currencies or oppressive cultures as a way of protecting people’s money, problems that Western countries without military dictatorships, extreme corruption, and hyperinflation cannot fully appreciate.

Securities vs. Commodities 

“There’s a broad consensus among market participants and advocacy groups that the SEC has done a poor job resolving uncertainty and providing regulatory clarity. We’ve seen SEC Chair Gary Genslers’s attitude in interviews telling crypto companies to register without providing a way for companies that don’t know if they’re securities or commodities and the government won’t tell them. That’s a bad environment generally,” says Zell. 

The Bitcoin Policy Institute isn’t advocating that all cryptocurrencies be regulated similarly. As Zell notes, many currencies, like Ethereum, have a top-down organizational structure and could qualify them as securities. Bitcoin, being fully decentralized with no controlling organizational structures, more readily qualifies as a commodity. Thus far, it has been very vague as to whether the SEC ought to concern various currencies as securities of commodities and regulate them respectively as such. 

“Much of the debate surrounds the Howey Test,” referring to the Supreme Court’s standard for determining if an item counts as a security based on whether it qualifies as an investment contract, “there’s so much back and forth about individual tokens and if they pass the Howey Test, but I assume a large amount of crypto do qualify as securities,” says Zell.  

“It speaks to the utility of these rules in the modern day that we’re using 70-year-old court cases to determine the fate of these new businesses and tokens. The regulatory framework is insufficient to meet the needs of entirely new business models. ” 

Home / News / The Future Of Bitcoin Regulation 
Share
FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Related Stories

Wall Street Makes $100 Billion Bet on Weight Loss Pills

by PJ Howland Leaders Staff
Investing

Oct 25, 2023

Ozempic

Investor optimism around a potential blockbuster obesity drug by Structure Therapeutics led to soaring share prices across the weight-loss pharma sector.

Key Details

  • Structure Therapeutics' stock jumped 35% after reporting positive results from early clinical trials of a once-daily weight-loss pill.
  • The experimental drug helped participants lose about 5% of their body weight over one month without side effects, although there are concerns with Ozempic.
  • Analysts predict the global anti-obesity medication market could reach sales of $100 billion by 2030, up from $71 billion currently.
  • With promising growth prospects, investors are betting on companies developing new weight loss drugs like Structure, Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk, and Pfizer.

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Seattle Takes The Crown For Advanced Tech Talent

by PJ Howland Leaders Staff
Tech

Oct 24, 2023

Seattle tech talent

Seattle has emerged as the metro area with the most advanced tech talent, beating out tech hubs like San Francisco and Silicon Valley.

Key Details

  • According to a new ranking by the Burning Glass Institute, Seattle has the highest proportion of advanced tech workers compared to other cities with similarly sized tech workforces.
  • The ranking evaluated 60 million high-paying, in-demand tech job postings and histories to identify cities with cutting-edge roles like AI and cybersecurity rather than legacy tech positions.
  • With tech giants Amazon and Microsoft headquartered in Seattle, the city edged out the San Francisco Bay Area, Boston, Austin, and Raleigh on the list.
  • The report found that demand for software developers and IT support specialists has declined over the past five years as companies seek more specialized tech talent.

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

More Americans Can’t Keep Up With Car Payments

by Colin Baker Leaders Staff
Loans and Borrowing

Oct 23, 2023

car loans, used cars

A record number of Americans are behind on their car loan payments as higher interest rates and prices weigh on consumers.

Key Details

  • According to data from Fitch Ratings, 6.11% of car loans were at least 60 days delinquent in September, the highest since tracking began in the early 2000s.
  • Some interest rates on used cars can rise to as much as 21%, according to Bankrate.
  • Soaring prices and rising interest rates are squeezing consumers, making it difficult for some to keep up with their auto loans.

Go deeper

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Chevron Gas Deal
Markets

Oct 23, 2023

Chevron Makes $53 Billion Deal Amid Surging Gas Prices

by PJ Howland Leaders Staff
nike logo
Company Culture

Oct 20, 2023

Nike to Require More In-Office Days From Employees

by Colin Baker Leaders Staff
blue collar workers
Retirement

Oct 20, 2023

Explaining The ‘C+ Grade’ Retirement Ecosystem in The United States

by PJ Howland Leaders Staff

Recent Articles

Hiring

Nov 1, 2023

Learn the Winning Answers to the Most Common Phone Interview Questions

Come to your next phone interview fully prepared

Personal Growth

Oct 30, 2023

85 Quotes on Self-Love to Boost Your Self-Esteem

Don’t fall into the trap of harsh self-criticism

Company Culture

Oct 27, 2023

What is a Sabbatical? Your Ticket to Restful Growth and Meaning

Sabbaticals can benefits both employees and businesses

  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Wealth
Join the Leaders Community

Get exclusive tools and resources you need to grow as a leader and scale a purpose-driven business.

Subscribing indicates your consent to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Leaders.com
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Careers
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms
  • Disclosures
  • Editorial Policy
  • Member Login

© 2023 Leaders.com - All rights reserved.

Search Leaders.com